View Point- The Dive Buddy issue

[Vtach]

Mike, your viewpoint is interesting. :  Where do you get your numbers regarding heart failure and diving?  I would also like to see your source for numbers regarding your point on certifications beyond AOW.  So an AOW certification is safer in regards to any type of dive?
I guess I disagree with your viewpoint regarding criticism.  As long as it is constructive I welcome it openly.  If it can make my diving safer and more enjoyable I'm open to listening.

I don't think the buddy system is a false sense of security for new divers.  Not following the buddy system is the false sense.  It works if used.  Therein lies the problem.  An experienced diver should never put their new diver buddy in a spot where they are beyond their ability to handle a problem (a good buddy wouldn't do that).  There should be no reason a new diver should be unable to help an experienced diver and also no reason that an experienced divers shouldn't have the knowledge or equipment to manage whatever situation occurs on a dive that is appropriate for both divers.  The problems occur when an "experienced" diver is overconfident and think that they are the shizzle.  Overconfidence leads to complacency and complacency is what kills.

I also disagree with the charter boat thing.  If you get on a charter boat without a buddy you are either planning a solo dive or rolling the dice with the other solo diver....  There is no forcing by the Captain.  If you don't want to dive with someone you don't know, sit on the boat and get to know the Captain.  They probably know more about competent divers than most divers.